Welcome to Natalie’s Bakery!
Freshly baked pies, cookies, and loaves made with love just for you. Whether you’re celebrating something special or craving a cozy homemade snack, you’re in the right place!
Take a look around, and if you see something you love, don’t hesitate to reach out or place an order. Thanks for stopping by—I’m so glad you’re here!
GLUTEN FREE, DAIRY FREE, AND VEGAN OPTIONS ARE NOT AVAILABLE
Pies
Apple Pie
$32.00
Freshly baked homemade Apple Pie! Each pie is made from scratch using fresh ingredients and a buttery flaky crust. Perfect for dessert, gifting, or just treating yourself because… you deserve it!
Pumpkin Pie
$28.00
Each slice of this pumpkin puree dessert will make your mouth melt with both satisfaction, and a craving for more. It’s a perfect dessert to complement your thanksgiving feast, or to just share with friends!
Pecan Pie
$28.00
This pie is sweet, crunchy, and seriously delicious. Every bite has that perfect mix of gooey and nutty that makes you want another slice right away. It’s the kind of dessert that makes family dinners, holidays, or just a regular day feel special.
Cookies
SERVED IN A DOZEN
Chocolate Chip Cookies
$20.00
These little treats are amazing, with just the right ratio of cookie to chocolate, with a bit of salt to enhance the already amazing flavor. Just one or two of these will have your sweet craving satisfied!
Snickerdoodle Cookies
$20.00
These chewy desserts are everything you could want. The delicious cinnamon-covered cookie offers satisfaction for all. Whether you want them for yourself, a gift, or a party, these will give you the satisfaction you wanted.
Cinnamon Pop-Tart Cookies
$28.00
These treats are a cinnamon sugar Pop-Tart all in one cookie. The cookie itself is amazing, but with the cinnamon glaze on the top, complemented by the cinnamon filling, this cookie really brings out the same feeling you get when you eat a cinnamon Pop-Tart!
Other Treats
Banana Loaf
$18.00
W/ chocolate chips - $19.00
Homemade Banana Bread! Immerse yourself in a loaf of tasty banana goodness, having the option of semi-sweet chocolate chips to have that extra bit of flavor. Perfect treat for dessert, gifting, or just treating yourself.